Post by Rick RussellPost by Frank F. MatthewsSorry Rick but employers should not be able to force a choice between
employment and health. A lot of miners died in the last century before
that became established.
No doubt. But should local governments make that choice? City
governments are ill-equipped to evaluate scientific data on workplace
risk. That's why we have federally mandated workplace safety
rules.
Along similar lines, local governments have a long history of pleasing
vocal minorities at the cost of the majority. OK, maybe that's all
governments. But in general, I'd like to see a clear mandate before
local government makes such a big change. Why not put it to a
referendum? I know Bob Lanier made referendum a dirty word, but it's
still the closest thing we've got to a real measure of city opinion.
Rick R.
I don't frequent non-smoking restaurants. I am glad that there are some
for non-smokers to enjoy. I noticed that where they ban it in bars that
except for kids who were there for the exclusive activity of picking
each other up that most bars were empty. We travel and eat out most of
the year. Minnesota and Alabama got lots of my money this year. Ca got
very little of it. In fact, I moved 60 million bucks of business to
another state because of their rules which even banned smoking OUTSIDE
in many places..
The few places that tried a voluntary complete smoking ban in
restaurants all failed as far as I could find. In almost every case,
there were businesses that had to re-institute smoking areas because of
a major loss of business.
I don't like the state coercing me to go to restaurants that I don't
enjoy by forcing the owner of these establishments to not choose whether
to allow it or not.
In NY, they banned smoking in bars. The owner is responsible for
enforcement so they "rent" ashtrays for a $1 and save up the collected
money to pay the fines. I overwhelming majority of their customers smoke.
Most studies that I have read actually show that smokers eat out
substantially more often and spend more money. The reason they try to
ban smoking exclusively is to make sure that the restaurants don't lose
this lucrative segment of their business. Those lingering smokers are
usually buying high profit drinks and additional food items. They also
generally do NOT have a bunch of low profit kids with the extra cleanup
time and costs.
Unlike the other poster, I usually see smoking sections filled and with
non-smoking empty seats on the other side.
As I stated, I am glad non-smokers have places. I just don't want to be
forced to consort with their kind by the state...... <grin>
My family does not have predispositions to health problems from smoking.
The vast majority live to their 90s and many well past a hundred and
they smoked.. My great grandfather died at 108 and his wife at 106 a few
months later. He died of viral pneumonia. With the shot, who knows how
long he would have lived. My great grandmother obviously gave up after
he died. They were married over 90 years. This on my father's side. My
mother's parents both lived over 100.
The two oldest people recorded were both smokers, both male and female.
The lady, Jeanne Calment, 122 years old, gave up smoking at 120
because she lost her sight and was too proud to ask someone to light her
up!! Shigechiyo Izumi, the man, died at 120 years of age; he also
smoked. The Japanese have the highest life span on the planet and they
also have a very high rate of smokers, in fact, the majority of men
there smoke and a large percentage of women do also.
==================================================
Life Expectancy top 15
(years) Smokers Prevalence
(percentages)
1. Iceland 76.6 (1994) 31.0 (1994)
2. Japan 76.5 (1994) 59.0 (1994)
3. Costa Rica 75.9 (1994) 35.0 (1988)
. Israel 75.9 (1994) 45.0 (1990)
5. Sweden 75.5 (1994) 22.0 (1994)
6. Greece 75.2 (1994) 46.0 (1994)
7. Switzerland 74.8 (1994) 36.0 (1992)
8. Netherlands 74.7 (1994) 36.0 (1994)
. Canada 74.7 (1994) 31.0 (1991)
. Cuba 74.7 (1994) 49.3 (1990)
11. Australia 74.5 (1994) 29.0 (1993)
. Spain 74.5 (1994) 48.0 (1993)
. Malta 74.5 (1994) 40.0 (1992)
14. Italy 74.4 (1994) 38.0 (1994)
15. France 74.3 (1994) 40.0 (1993)
US added for comparison
... USA 72.6 (1994) 28.1 (1991)